Skip to main content
SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory
LCLSLinac Coherent Light Source

User Portal Login   |  LCLS Internal Site

Main navigation

  • About
    • Organizational Chart
    • People & Committees
      • Leadership
      • Users' Executive Committee
      • Scientific Advisory Committee
      • LCLS Detector Advisory Committee
      • Proposal Review Panel
      • SLAC Photon Science Faculty
      • Users' Recognition Award
      • Young Investigator Award
    • Strategic Plan 2023-2028
    • Our Science
    • Internships
      • Intern Testimonials
      • Summer Student Poster Sessions
    • Jobs
    • Multimedia
      • Virtual Tours
      • Fact Sheets & Infographics
      • Image Gallery
      • Youtube Videos
    • Coming to SLAC
    • Contact Us
  • User Resources
    • User Research Administration (URA) Office
    • Schedules
    • Proposals
      • Proposal Preparation Guidelines
      • MeV-UED Proposals
      • Proposal Review Process
      • Run 25 Proposal Call
      • Universal Proposal System (UPS)
      • Submit Proposal
      • Archived Proposal Calls
    • User Agreements
    • Policies
    • Proprietary Research
    • Safety & Training
      • Work Planning & Control
      • LCLS Building Orientation
      • Hutch 6 Non-Permit Confined Space Training
      • Sample Delivery Training
      • Sample Prep Lab Training
    • SLAC User Access Requirements
      • Computer Accounts
      • Data Collection & Analysis (PCDS)
      • DAQ
      • Shipping Equipment & Materials
      • Financial Accounts
    • Links By Category
  • Publications
    • LCLS Publications
    • Search Publications
    • Submit New Publication
    • Archived Publications
  • Instruments
    • chemRIXS
      • Science Goals
      • Experimental Methods
      • Specifications
      • Standard Configurations
      • Publications
    • CXI
      • Experimental Methods
      • Specifications
      • Components
      • Standard Configurations
      • Publications
    • MEC
      • Science Goals
      • Experimental Methods
      • Specifications
      • Diagnostics & Components
      • Standard Configurations
      • Lasers & Beam Delivery
      • Publications
    • MFX
      • Science Goals
      • Experimental Methods
      • Specifications
      • Standard Configurations
      • Publications
    • qRIXS
      • Science Goals
      • Experimental Methods
      • Layout & Specifications
      • Capabilities
    • TMO
      • Science Goals
      • Layout & Specifications
      • Standard Configuration
      • Publications
    • TXI
      • Science Goals
      • Experimental Methods
      • Layout & Specifications
    • XCS
      • Experimental Methods
      • Specifications
      • Components
      • Standard Configurations
      • Operation Modes
      • Publications
    • XPP
      • Science Goals
      • Experimental Methods
      • Specifications
      • Components
      • Standard Configurations
      • Publications
    • MeV-UED
      • Specifications
      • Run 6 Scientific Capabilities
      • Schematics
      • Endstations
      • Proposals
      • Proposal Review Process
      • Schedule
      • Publications
    • LCLS-II-HE
    • DXS
      • Science Goals
      • Experimental Methods
      • Specifications
    • Instrument Maps
    • Standard Configurations
  • Machine
    • Machine Status
    • Machine FAQ (NC Linac)
    • Parameters
    • Schedules
  • Projects
    • LCLS-II
      • Science
      • Design & Performance
      • Commissioning
    • LCLS-II-HE
      • Science
      • Design & Performance
      • Meetings and Reports
      • Instruments
      • Internal Site
    • MEC-U
      • Science Mission
      • Design & Performance
      • Workshops & Meetings
      • Publications
      • News
      • Resources & Photos
      • Internal Site
  • Departments
    • SRD Leadership
    • Atomic, Molecular, & Optical Sciences
      • Research Interests
      • People
      • Research Highlights
      • Attosecond Science Campaign
    • Biological Sciences & Sample Preparations
      • Sample Environment & Delivery
      • Sample Preparation Laboratories
      • Biolabs at the Arrillaga Science Center (ASC)
      • Equipment Inventory
      • Chemical Inventory
    • Chemical Sciences
      • Research Interests
      • People
      • News & Highlights
      • Publications
    • Material Sciences
      • Research Interests
      • People
    • Matter in Extreme Conditions
      • Research Interests
      • People
      • Publications
    • Laser Sciences
      • Research Interests
      • Laser Capabilities​
      • People
      • User Resources
    • Detectors
      • Technologies
      • People
      • User Resources
    • Experiment Data Systems
      • Infrastructure
      • People
      • Projects
      • User Resources
    • Experiment Control Systems
      • Leadership
  • News
    • LCLS Science SLAC News Feed
    • Announcements & Updates
    • External News Features
      • Archive
  • Links

Breadcrumb

  1. Home
  2. Instruments
  3. MeV-UED (Megaelectronvolt Ultrafast Electron Diffraction)
  4. …
Facebook Share X Post LinkedIn Share Email Send
  • chemRIXS
    • Science Goals
    • Experimental Methods
    • Specifications
    • Standard Configurations
    • Publications
  • CXI
    • Experimental Methods
    • Specifications
    • Components
    • Standard Configurations
    • Publications
  • MEC
    • Science Goals
    • Experimental Methods
    • Specifications
    • Diagnostics & Components
    • Standard Configurations
    • Lasers & Beam Delivery
    • Publications
  • MFX
    • Science Goals
    • Experimental Methods
    • Specifications
    • Standard Configurations
    • Publications
  • qRIXS
    • Science Goals
    • Experimental Methods
    • Layout & Specifications
    • Capabilities
  • TMO
    • Science Goals
    • Layout & Specifications
    • Standard Configuration
    • Publications
  • TXI
    • Science Goals
    • Experimental Methods
    • Layout & Specifications
  • XCS
    • Experimental Methods
    • Specifications
    • Components
    • Standard Configurations
    • Operation Modes
    • Publications
  • XPP
    • Science Goals
    • Experimental Methods
    • Specifications
    • Components
    • Standard Configurations
    • Publications
  • MeV-UED
    • Specifications
    • Run 6 Scientific Capabilities
    • Schematics
    • Endstations
    • Proposals
    • Proposal Review Process
    • Schedule
    • Publications
  • LCLS-II-HE
  • DXS
    • Science Goals
    • Experimental Methods
    • Specifications
  • Instrument Maps
  • Standard Configurations

MeV-UED Proposal Review Process

Proposal Evaluation Criteria

Proposals must provide sufficient information to evaluate the impact, originality, need for the MeV-UED instrument, scientific risk, prior results, as well as technical feasibility. Proposal evaluation criteria include:

  • Scientific Impact: Does the proposal address a question that, if successfully answered by the proposed experiment, will have a strong impact either on the scientific field or technological area addressed by the research?
  • Originality/New Scientific Field: If successful, does the proposal open a new field?
  • Need for the MeV-UED instrument/Experimental Plans: To what extent is MeV-UED critical for the success of this proposal? Can other techniques or facilities provide similar information about the scientific question?
  • Scientific Risk: Evaluate the probability that the proposed research will yield significant new results.
  • Prior Results: Evaluate success or progress of prior experiments.
  • Feasibility: MeV-UED scientists conduct a preliminary technical feasibility review of submitted proposals.
  • Compatibility: Does the experiment require significant modifications to any of the proposed MeV-UED instrument configurations? 

Proposal Review Process

LCLS & MeV-UED management work very closely with the LCLS Scientific Advisory Committee (SAC), Proposal Review Panel (PRP), the Users' Executive Committee (UEC), and the MeV-UED Program Advisory Committee (PAC) to develop a fair and transparent external peer review process. MeV-UED proposal review and ranking is carried out in a similar fashion to the LCLS Proposal Review Panel (PRP) which includes international experts divided into several subpanels: solid-state/materials (SSM), single-shot/warm dense matter physics (WDM), and gas/liquid-phase chemistry/AMO (CHE).  A description of the proposal review process follows.

The proposal review process begins as soon as each call for proposals is closed, with an on-site PRP meeting at SLAC approximately two months after the proposal deadline. Concurrent with the PRP review, MeV-UED scientists conduct a technical feasibility review of submitted proposals. Proposals determined not to be feasible may be removed from further consideration before the PRP meets, and the proposal spokesperson will be informed.

Users indicate the appropriate PRP panel(s) to review their proposals when submitting proposals through the user portal. Proposals are reviewed by MeV-UED and the PRP Chairs to confirm that the distribution of proposals is appropriate for the expertise of the PRP or to reassign these proposals to more appropriate subpanels to facilitate consistency in the review and ranking process. Once the subpanel assignments are confirmed, the PRP chairs assign 2-3 reviewers for each proposal assigned to their subpanel. Additional reviews may be requested from other panels if the area of science extends beyond the primary subpanel. If the PRP lacks the necessary expertise to review any proposal, subpanel chairs may request ad hoc external peer reviewers to supplement the PRP review.

LCLS and MeV-UED management provides clear guidance to PRP members to mitigate potential conflicts of interest. See guidelines for managing potential Conflicts of Interest in the Proposal Review Panels.

In time for the PRP meeting, reviewers provide a written review for each assigned proposal summarizing their findings.

Subpanel chairs assign a 'Lead Reviewer' for each proposal, who presents the proposal during the subpanel deliberations. The panels define a prioritized list of proposals based on the criteria listed above. Prioritization between sub-panels is determined according to a pro-rata weighting based on the number of applications in each area. Within one week of the PRP meeting the subpanel chairs will provide comments on each proposal with sufficient detail to explain the basis of the panel's assessment, to help the proposal teams address any deficiencies and improve their proposals for a subsequent review cycle. 

The ranked list of proposals will be the guide for LCLS & MeV-UED management to award beam time. LCLS has the discretion to consider aspects beyond the strict ranking to make the final beam time allocation. Such considerations may include issues of programmatic and community diversity, access to new instruments, utilization of beamtime (e.g. via multiplexing and efficient use of standard configurations), funding restrictions and other aspects.

Register as a user and submit MeV-UED proposals through the Universal Proposal System

MeV-UED Proposal Review Panel

The facility would like to extend our sincere thanks to the members of our Proposal Review Panels for their thoughtful reviews and the time and effort they have invested.  The panels dedication and expertise have been invaluable in helping the LCLS MeV-UED facility achieve its goal of delivering the highest quality scientific output. 

MeV-UED Contacts

Alex Reid

MeV-UED Facility Director & Instrument Lead
(650) 926-7467
alexhmr@slac.stanford.edu

Joel England

MeV-UED Accelerator Lead
(650) 926-3706
england@slac.stanford.edu

Stephen Weathersby

Area Manager
(650) 926-3890
spw@slac.stanford.edu

Ming-Fu Lin

Lead Scientist
(650) 926-2586
mfucb@slac.stanford.edu

Matthias Hoffmann

Lead Laser Scientist
(650) 926-4446
hoffmann@slac.stanford.edu

Xinxin Cheng

Staff Scientist
xcheng@slac.stanford.edu

Patrick Kramer

Laser Scientist
(650) 926-5148
pkramer@slac.stanford.edu

Randy Lemons

Laser Scientist
(650) 926-3477
rlemons@slac.stanford.edu

Cameron Duncan

Associate Scientist
cjduncan@slac.stanford.edu

Fuhao Ji

Associate Scientist
(650) 926-4678
fuhaoji@slac.stanford.edu

Yusong Liu

Associate Scientist
yusongl@slac.stanford.edu

Aaron Garza

Staff Engineer
(650) 926-4282
aarongs@slac.stanford.edu

Ian Roque

Staff Engineer
(650) 926-3407
iroque@slac.stanford.edu

Tianzhe Xu

Research Associate
txu@slac.stanford.edu

Sharon S. Philip

Research Associate
sharonsp@slac.stanford.edu

LCLS | Linac Coherent Light Source
2575 Sand Hill Road MS103
Menlo Park, CA 94025
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Flickr
  • Youtube
  • LinkedIn
  • Staff portal
  • Privacy policy
  • Accessibility
  • Vulnerability disclosure
SLAC
  • SLAC home
  • Maps & directions
  • Emergency info
  • Careers

© 2025 SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory is operated by Stanford University for the U.S. Department of Energy Office of Science.

Stanford University U.S. Department of Energy
Top Top
Back to top Back to top